From the very first episode, Madlyn expressed her reluctance to accept a proposal from Colby.
She is quick to admit Colby annoys her.
“He’s always putting on a show,” she shared (viaNetflix).

Madlyn’s friends weren’t the biggest fans of her boyfriend.
In a confessional, Maeson revealed that she and Colby had hooked up in college.
“Wasn’t really something rememberable,” she admitted.

“On an attractive level, I definitely think Randall would be a better lover.”
By the end of the interaction, Madlyn’s friends were very much Team Randall.
Talk about a happy ending for the lovebirds!

In the reunion episode, Nick Lachey addresses the dislike that Madlyn’s friends had for Colby.
“My friends are just 100% support Madlyn,” the reality TV star shared (viaNetflix).
“So, at that moment I wasn’t liking Colby so they don’t like Colby.”
“They back me no matter what.
So they back Colby now too,” she continued.