From the very first episode, Madlyn expressed her reluctance to accept a proposal from Colby.

She is quick to admit Colby annoys her.

“He’s always putting on a show,” she shared (viaNetflix).

A close-up shot of Madlyn from the Ultimatum

Madlyn’s friends weren’t the biggest fans of her boyfriend.

In a confessional, Maeson revealed that she and Colby had hooked up in college.

“Wasn’t really something rememberable,” she admitted.

Madlyn and Randall from “The Ultimatum”

“On an attractive level, I definitely think Randall would be a better lover.”

By the end of the interaction, Madlyn’s friends were very much Team Randall.

Talk about a happy ending for the lovebirds!

Colby and Madlyn touching baby bump

In the reunion episode, Nick Lachey addresses the dislike that Madlyn’s friends had for Colby.

“My friends are just 100% support Madlyn,” the reality TV star shared (viaNetflix).

“So, at that moment I wasn’t liking Colby so they don’t like Colby.”

“They back me no matter what.

So they back Colby now too,” she continued.