Will Amy Sherman-Palladino grace us with another season of this family dramedy?

The jury is still out (viaPeople).

However, no topic is more hotly debated than Rory’s love interests.

Matt Czuchry at the “Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life” premiere

In an interview withUs Weekly, someone especially close to the matter weighed in on this contentious topic.

The person in question?

Matt Czuchry aka Logan Huntzberger.

A photo of Rory and Logan talking as Logan adjusts his tie

He wanted to follow his heart with love, which was Rory," Czuchry continued.

To top that off, Logan and Rory’s timing wasn’t right.

When Logan proposed to Rory, the aspiring journalist wasn’t ready to get married.

Jared Padalecki

“I actually liked how Rory refused Logan’s proposal.

As for whether Rory is pregnant with Logan’s baby?

Czuchry’s lips are sealed.

Alexis Bledel has remained strictly neutral in the debate.

“I can’t single somebody out.”

We’ll give you points for creativity, Alexis.

As for other Stars Hollow natives?

Several other cast members have marked themselves as decidedly Team Jess, including both Scott Patterson and Keiko Agena.