While Kissinger was ready to settle down and get married, Ballatori was more on the fence.
Although it’s quite a familiar sticking point for couples, what happened next was less common.
The pair went onNetflix’s latest realitydating show, “The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On.”

Colby:I’m still riding the same train.
I threw [it] into a different gear, pretty much.
I knew within the first few months that she was the one.

She was incredible from day one, and I chased her.
I knew where my feelings were at, and they were very strong.
Madlyn:It’s hard, and there’s no one right way for everybody.

It can be wonderful.
Do either of you have any concerns for the show coming out?
We did the best we could, so it’s dealing with it one day at a time.
No real regrets or concerns.
We’ll be all right.